Quick answer: To choose a virtual assistant company, stop comparing sales pitches and compare the same ten facts from every provider: who employs the assistant, the hours, the monthly price, extra fees, the minimum term and notice period, who picks the hire, how long the search takes, replacement terms, the screening steps, and references from businesses like yours. Write the answers down after each call, then interview real candidates from your top two providers before you sign anything.
Many buyers we talk to have already had several intro calls by the time they reach us, and the calls start to blur together. One buyer put it plainly on a call with us: "For a true comparison I would need to compare a VA to a VA, not a VA to a presentation." This guide gives you a way to do that. If you want a ranked list of providers to start from, see our roundup of the best virtual assistant companies. This article covers how to choose a virtual assistant company once you have a shortlist, and how to compare virtual assistant companies on facts you can check.
What should you write down after every virtual assistant company call?
Write down the same ten facts after every call, in the same order, so you can put providers side by side a week later. The facts that matter are structural: who the assistant's legal employer is, how many hours you get, the monthly price, any fees beyond it, the minimum term and notice period, whether you interview and choose the hire, how long the search takes, what happens if the assistant leaves, which screening steps the company actually runs, and which references it can give you. These are the things that change your costs, risks, and ability to cancel. Adjectives like "top talent" and "hand-picked" don't belong on the sheet, because every provider uses them. If a company can't answer one of the ten questions on the call, write "no answer" in that box. A blank is information too. The scorecard below is the virtual assistant company checklist we'd use ourselves, with our own answers filled in as an example.
| Scorecard row | Question to ask every provider | Example: Stellar Staff's answer |
|---|---|---|
| Legal employer | Who employs the assistant and runs payroll? | Stellar Staff handles recruiting, payroll, HR, tracking, and replacements. You direct the hire's daily work. |
| Hours | Is the assistant dedicated to you, and for how many hours a month? | Full-time, 160 hours a month |
| Monthly price | What is the monthly price, and what does it include? | Pro $1,999/month; Executive $2,999/month; bilingual +$200/month |
| Other fees | Are there setup, placement, or conversion fees? | Custom Recruitment is a separate service, from $4,999 one-time |
| Term and notice | Is there a minimum term? How much notice do you need to cancel? | Month to month, no long-term contract, cancel with 14 days' notice |
| Who picks the hire | Do you interview candidates and make the final choice? | You interview 2 to 3 finalists and pick one |
| Search time | How long until you see finalists? | The search takes 5 to 10 business days |
| Replacements | What does a replacement cost, and for how long is it offered? | Free, forever, on managed plans |
| Screening | Which screening steps does every candidate go through? | 6-step application and 6 individual tests, English verification (written and spoken), reference checks, equipment check, professional interviews and skill assessments, internal QA, background checks |
| Proof | Which references, reviews, or case studies can you check? | #2 VA agency on Clutch; published case studies |
Copy the first two columns into a spreadsheet and add a column for each company you speak with. Better yet, email the questions before the call and ask for written answers. A company that answers in writing is easier to hold to those answers later.
Which claims do all VA companies make that you can't verify?
The claims you can't verify are the ones every provider makes: "we hire the top 1%," "we hand-select our staff," "our assistants are the best in the industry," and "we find the perfect fit." You have no way to audit an acceptance rate from the outside, and you can't see the applicants a company turned down. That doesn't make these claims false. We make one ourselves: Stellar Staff hires from the top 0.1% of applicants, out of thousands of applicants a month. But a buyer comparing five companies will hear five versions of the same promise, and none of them helps you choose. One buyer summed it up on a call: "Everyone says the same thing, we hand select our staff. How are you different?" The useful move is to translate each claim into something you can check. Ask which screening steps happen, in what order, and what a candidate has to pass. Then judge the result directly by interviewing the people the process produces.
A few translations that work on a sales call:
- "We only hire the best" becomes "Which tests does every candidate take, and can I see a sample?"
- "Our VAs speak great English" becomes "How do you verify written and spoken English, and can I talk to a finalist live?"
- "We're very selective" becomes "How many finalists will I interview for my role?"
- "We take care of everything" becomes "Which tasks are mine, and which are yours, after the assistant starts?"

Who employs the assistant, and why does it matter to you?
The legal employer decides who pays the assistant, who handles their taxes and benefits, who handles a resignation, and who replaces them. With an agency, the assistant usually works for the agency or for a partner it uses, and you pay the agency one monthly bill. With a freelance marketplace, you're typically hiring an independent contractor yourself, so the screening, payment, and replacement fall to you. With a direct hire abroad, you either set up local employment or use an employer of record. Ask every provider, "Who is the assistant's employer, and who pays them?" A vague answer is a warning sign. In the U.S., a contract label alone doesn't settle whether someone is an employee or a contractor. The IRS says the key is the entire relationship and the extent of the right to direct and control the worker. The assistant's home country has its own rules too.
Our guide to outsourcing to the Philippines compares the legal employer under each model. For the marketplace route, see Upwork vs Fiverr for hiring a virtual assistant. On the call, also ask whether the assistant works for any other clients. A dedicated full-time assistant and a shared assistant who splits the day among several businesses can have the same title but work very differently.
Which contract terms actually differ from one provider to the next?
Pitches sound the same, but contracts don't. The terms that vary most between providers are the minimum term, the notice period, setup or placement fees, the cost to hire the assistant directly later, replacement terms, and when billing starts. Two companies with the same monthly price can be far apart once you add a minimum term, a deposit, and a long notice period. Ask each provider to send the actual agreement, not a summary, and check that the answers you wrote on your scorecard match the document. If the salesperson said "month to month" and the contract says something else, the contract wins. Our virtual assistant contract template explains the clauses one by one, and our virtual assistant fees checklist covers every charge that can appear beyond the monthly rate.
| Term | What you'll hear from different providers | What to get in writing |
|---|---|---|
| Minimum term | Month to month, or a fixed commitment of several months | The exact start and end of any commitment |
| Notice period | Anywhere from a couple of weeks to a couple of months | Notice days, how to give notice, and the final billing date |
| Upfront money | None, a deposit, or a placement fee | What it covers and whether it's credited toward your first month |
| Replacements | Free, free for a limited window, or a new placement fee | The cost, any time limit, and how fast a replacement search starts |
| Direct hire | Not allowed, allowed with a fee, or allowed after a set period | The fee or waiting period, stated in dollars and months |
| Billing start | On signing, when you pick a finalist, or on the first workday | The date the first invoice is issued |
What should replacement terms say?
Assistants sometimes leave, and some placements don't work out. Replacement terms tell you what that costs you. Get three things in writing: whether a replacement is free, whether that applies for the whole relationship or only a short window, and whether you interview the replacement candidates the same way you did the first time. At Stellar Staff, replacements are free, forever, on managed plans.
How do you compare an hourly quote with a flat monthly price?
Convert every quote into the same unit before you compare it. For a monthly plan, ask how many hours the price includes and divide the monthly price by those hours. For an hourly quote, ask how many hours you'd realistically buy each month, how time is tracked, whether hours are billed in minimum increments, and whether unused hours roll over or expire. Then check what the number buys. A low hourly rate for a few hours a week from a shared assistant is a different product from a dedicated full-time hire, even if the effective rate looks similar. Also ask whether the rate changes for overtime, night shifts, holidays, or bilingual work. For reference, our Pro plan is about $12.50 an hour, for a full-time assistant at 160 hours a month. Before you compare full-time and part-time quotes, read why many agencies only sell full-time in our guide to part-time vs full-time virtual assistants.
For market rates, see how much a virtual assistant costs. To compare a VA with a local hire instead, see virtual assistant vs employee costs.
Why should you compare candidates instead of sales presentations?
Because you're hiring a person, not a company's slide deck. The salesperson won't be answering your phones or managing your calendar. The assistant will. Two providers with nearly identical pitches can send you very different finalists, and the only way to see that is to interview them. Before you commit to any provider, ask how many finalists you'll meet, whether you make the final choice yourself, and whether you can give each finalist a short, realistic task from your own work. Then run the same interview and the same task with the finalists from each company you're considering. Score their answers, their written English, and how they handle a question they don't know the answer to. Our guide to how to hire a virtual assistant has interview questions and what good answers sound like.
How long should it take to see finalists?
Ask every provider for a date, not a word like "fast" or "right away." A company that promises someone the same day is usually offering whoever is available, not someone matched to your role. At Stellar Staff, the search takes 5 to 10 business days, and you interview 2 to 3 finalists and pick one. For a stage-by-stage view and how to plan back from a start date, see how long it takes to hire a virtual assistant.

When is it reasonable to pay before you see any candidates?
Paying before you see candidates is reasonable when the provider is doing real, custom recruiting work for you, the fee is stated in writing, and you know exactly what you get if no candidate works out. A one-time recruiting fee for a hard-to-fill or specialized role can fit that description. It's harder to justify a large deposit or several months of prepayment for a standard role, before you've met anyone, with no written terms on what happens if the finalists aren't a fit. Ask every provider three questions: "What do I pay before I see candidates? What does that payment cover? What happens to it if I don't hire anyone?" Then compare that with a month-to-month plan with short notice. In practice, a short notice period works much like a trial, because you can leave without a long commitment if the fit isn't right. A long minimum term paired with a "trial week" does not give you the same flexibility.
At Stellar Staff, plans are month to month with no long-term contract, and you can cancel with 14 days' notice. Custom Recruitment is a separate service, from $4,999 one-time.
Which references should you ask a virtual assistant company for?
Ask for references that match your situation: a business in your industry, with a similar role, that has worked with the provider for a while. A glowing reference from a different industry tells you less than a plain one from a business like yours. When you call a reference, ask what the assistant actually does each day, how the first month went, whether the company had to replace anyone and how that was handled, and what they'd do differently. Then check public reviews on sites the provider doesn't control, and read the negative reviews as carefully as the positive ones. Look at how the company responded. Since the FTC announced its final rule on fake reviews on August 14, 2024, businesses have been barred from buying fake reviews, posting undisclosed insider reviews, and running review sites that pose as independent while promoting their own products.
Published case studies help when they name the client and describe the actual work. For example, our case studies cover a dental office's insurance verification assistant and a law firm's virtual assistants. Healthcare buyers should also ask who signs the business associate agreement. See our HIPAA-compliant virtual assistant guide.
What red flags should take a company off your list?
Take a company off your list when it won't put its answers in writing, won't tell you who employs the assistant, or won't let you interview and choose the person you'll work with. Those three gaps make every other promise hard to enforce. Other red flags are pressure to sign a long-term contract before you've met any candidates, pricing you only hear on a call and never see in a quote, replacement terms that exist only as a verbal promise, and an assistant described as dedicated who turns out to split time across several clients. Be careful with reviews that appear only on the company's own website, and with a provider that can't describe its screening steps beyond "we're very selective." None of these proves a company is bad, but each one adds risk you can't measure. The table pairs each red flag with the question that brings it out.
| Red flag | Why it matters | Question that brings it out |
|---|---|---|
| No written answers | Verbal promises are hard to enforce | "Can you send these answers in an email?" |
| Unclear employer | You can't tell who handles pay, taxes, or a resignation | "Who is the assistant's legal employer?" |
| No interview | The provider picks the person you'll work with every day | "How many finalists will I interview, and who decides?" |
| Commitment first | You pay for months before you know the fit | "What's the minimum term, and when does billing start?" |
| Verbal replacements | The terms may change when you need them | "Where is the replacement policy in the agreement?" |
| Shared "dedicated" VA | Your work competes with other clients' work | "Does this assistant work for anyone else?" |
| Reviews only on the provider's site | You can't see the full picture | "Where can I read reviews you don't control?" |
How do you choose between two companies with similar prices?
When two providers are close on price, the price stops being the deciding factor. Go back to the scorecard and look for the rows where they differ. Usually the tiebreaker is one of four things: the quality of the finalists you interviewed, how quickly you can cancel if the arrangement doesn't work out, what happens if the assistant leaves, and how clearly each company answered your questions in writing. Give the finalists from both companies the same short task and compare the results side by side. Compare the notice periods and replacement terms in the actual agreements. If it's still a tie, pick the one with the shorter commitment. You lose less if you're wrong. To see how specific providers compare on these points, our comparison pages and our list of Stellar Staff alternatives summarize published terms company by company.
How do you present the comparison to a partner or board?
Keep it to one page. Show the scorecard for your top two providers, your recommendation, and the reason in one or two sentences. Add the monthly cost, the notice period, and what you'll check after the first 30 days, such as response times or tasks completed. Partners rarely object to a decision they can reverse quickly, so lead with the exit terms.
What Buyers Ask While Comparing VA Providers
What should I look for in a virtual assistant company?
Look for clear written answers on the legal employer, hours, price, fees, minimum term, notice period, replacement terms, and screening steps. Then look for proof: finalists you can interview, references from businesses like yours, and reviews on sites the company doesn't control. A company that answers all of these in writing is easier to compare and easier to hold to its promises.
What questions should I ask a virtual assistant company?
The most useful questions to ask a virtual assistant company are: Who employs the assistant? Is the assistant dedicated to me? What's the monthly price, and what fees come on top of it? What's the minimum term and notice period? Do I interview and choose the hire? How long until I see finalists? What does a replacement cost? Which references can I call?
How many virtual assistant companies should I talk to?
Three is usually enough to see the range of prices and terms. After that, extra calls add confusion more than information. Use the scorecard to narrow the list to two, then interview finalists from both. Comparing real candidates side by side is a better use of your time than a fourth or fifth sales presentation.
Is Stellar Staff legit?
Stellar Staff was founded in 2022 (formerly VA Support Now) by Russell German, Founder & CEO, and Slava Litvin, Co-Founder. It's the #2 VA agency on Clutch, with 1,000+ remote hires placed since 2022. Plans are month to month with 14 days' notice, and you interview 2 to 3 finalists before you pick one. You can check the Clutch reviews and case studies yourself.
Can I interview the virtual assistant before I sign up?
It depends on the provider, so ask before the first payment. Some companies assign an assistant without an interview. Others let you interview a shortlist and choose. If you'll work with the person every day, being able to interview finalists and make the final choice is one of the most important rows on your scorecard.
Is a virtual assistant agency better than hiring a freelancer?
Not always. A freelancer can be the better fit for a short project or a few hours a week. An agency is usually the better fit for ongoing, full-time work, because it handles recruiting, screening, and replacements. Compare what you'd have to do yourself under each option, not only the hourly rate.
Narrow It to Two Companies, Then Compare Their Candidates
Choosing a virtual assistant company gets easier once you stop comparing pitches. Fill out the same scorecard after every call, get the answers in writing, read the agreement before you compare prices, and interview finalists from your top two providers. The company whose candidates, terms, and written answers hold up best is usually the right choice.
A VA company isn't the right choice for every business. If you only have a few hours of work a week, a freelancer or a part-time arrangement may fit better. If the role needs a U.S. license, regular in-person work, or data your industry rules keep onshore, hire locally. And if you don't yet have tasks written down for someone to own, start there before you talk to any provider.
If Stellar Staff is on your shortlist, our pricing page lists the Pro and Executive plans, and our hiring page explains how the search and finalist interviews work.
General information, not legal or tax advice. Sources checked November 8, 2026. Stellar Staff pricing is current as of November 2026.




